Thankyou Dr Jensen, Mr Pell, Mr Fisher – Happy Easter!
April 3, 2010
As a part of Easter messages in Australia, atheists have copped an earful.
My first thoughts, aside from a mild irritation brought on by the sheer silliness of the claims, were that this was a beautiful thing. Yes.
I still feel this way today.
Dr Jensen
It was reported that Sydney Anglican Archbishop Dr Jensen, as part of his Easter address started out with a critique of atheists, that included sentiments along the lines of…
This post has been moved here…
30 Comments
Trackbacks
- Most Tweeted Articles by Biology Experts
- Bravus » I’m not an atheist, but…
- skepticlawyer » The Cats That Will Not Be Herded
- Tact not entirely decided upon… « Thinkers' Podium
Comments are closed.
Brilliant
*applauds*
Thanks guys. *Blushes*
Word!
If only someone could get “word” out to PZ, then maybe this post would really take off!
May be off on a tangent here, but here goes.
Must declare I was raised a catholic, however am now most definitely an athiest.
Never saw a reason to declare that fact but now interested in various responses.
One response which I believe requires a response is this constant retort by so called believers, that of Nazism ( faschism) being a godless idology. From my reading on this subject, the Papacy was very much involved in the overthrow of the Spanish Rebublic along with the other fascist states of Germany and Italy. And Eugenio Pacelli (later Pius XII) was very much involved with Hitlar’s Reicht.
It makes perfect sense that the Papacy saw faschism as the lesser of two evils because let’s face it, with commumist control of Europe the Papacy is out of business.
Interested in other opinions??
Well written, concise and a joy to read. Thankyou Bruce.
Bravo!
Christianity stands or falls on whether Jesus rose from the dead. All the rest is mere noise.
If Jesus didn’t rise from the dead, even the apostle Paul admitted that Christians might as well pack up and go home.
If Jesus did rise from the dead, however, then the central claims of Christianity become impossible to ignore or dismiss.
Neither side of this debate gains any credit by being shrill, dismissive or vindictive towards the other.
Happy Easter everybody!
I am a bedraggled refugee from the “Holy” Roman Catholic Church. I just want to say this to George Cardinal “Go to Hell” Pell:
GO TO YOUR HELL if the Devil will have you. I believe he does not want competition. At least I am luckier that you, Pell. I don’t believe in a Hell, or any “God”.
I bet you’re all middle aged, white, heterosexual males…who all lurve the caucasian/phallo-centric christianity.
forgot to insert: /sarcasm in the above post.
That would of been interpreted the wrong way.
Major blunder by me, sorry.
And the latest? The Irish Catholic Church is peeved at the Anglican leadership for being honest.
Meanwhile, Pope Benedict’s personal preacher, Father Raniero Cantalamessa, is under fire for stupidly likening criticism of the Church’s mishandling of clerical sex abuse to the persecution of Jews. Another fine example of a “sophisticated theologian”?
In the USA, Catholic League frontman Bill Donohue comes out firing, blaming homosexual priests for the Church’s endemic child abuse problem.
What is the next piece of bumbling buffoonery to come from these Keystone Kops of Christendom?
Dawkins nailed it (sic!) at Atheist Convention 2010. It’s ALL pure Monty Python. Rather, it would be funny if it weren’t so very very wrong.
Where have I heard that before?
Hello from Ukraine !
Yes, this the well written article, I enjoyed read, very much so, I say you thank you for it and, hello to you
Sincerely,
Marina.
Rivne [Rovno] Ukraine.
Great article.
The only thing I would have mentioned is the fact I do not need to believe in miraculous healing, walking on water, living in “big fish” for 3 days to be kind to other people.
Thanks for your considered thoughts, there are many NGOs that do much for our communities which are not established by a religious institution, who do not discriminate who they employ.
I am an atheist and am a CEO of one such NGO providing employment for people with disabilities. I employ over 140 people from many diverse backgrounds.
I also have a young family and often have to think carefully in response to the nonsense a teacher at their school has planted in my child’s head. I do this without casting prejudice or association to the many atrocities committed religious base societies throughout human history.
Regardless of beliefs, with a basic understanding of ethics nobody in management would make such public claims yet these so-called religious leaders can and do.
As a “non-god-botherer” I have no intention of wasting my life proving or disproving the existence of a invisible, all-powerful(?) celestial puppeteer, who exclusively represents the interests of one particular (chosen) group of people be it Jews, Christians, Muslims, Mormons or …Scientologists.
The likes of Mr.Pell, Mr.Fisher or Mr.Jensen desperately peddling their infantile religious myths and superstitions lose the intellectual and MORAL battle with the 21 century reality…and they know it.
Their recent public utterings are a pathetic attempt to save the sinking ship of the organised religion. The religious bosses clumsily try to divert out attention away from their real (self-made I must add) problems: their blatant hypocrisy, social and cultural inadequacy and moral bankruptcy of their “god-given” dogmas in this day and age, dwindling numbers of their “flocks” , desperate shortage of the priests, mass sell-out of church property to name a few.
As virtually unemployable men elsewhere they desperately cling to their “jobs” in the religiou$ bu$ine$$. I am not overly surprised after all it is their livelihood, the only thing they have known throughout their adult lives. I can almost sympathise with them. I am more or less of their age and I certainly would not like to lose my job. I do not wish it to anybody.
I respect Torah, the Bible and the Quaran as a part of the humanity’s literary tradition as much as we respect the Hindu, Aztec, Greek or Roman mythology.
In my home library The Qur’an, The King James Bible, The Torah and even the Book of Mormon coexist peacefully, side by side with the works of Aesop, Andersen, Grimm Brothers, Perrault and La Fontaine.
One more thing…please do not call people like myself “non-believers”. I do believe in the power of education and free enquiry, universal values, human solidarity…and The Golden Rule.
P.S.
Mr.Pell’s, Mr.Jensen’s and Mr.Fisher’s knowledge of modern history is embarrassing to say the least. I say it in the name of my godmother – KL Auschwitz prisoner number 25541 who from 1941 to 1945 witnessed and experienced first hand “Christian compassion” of god-fearing genocidal psychopaths German and Austrian camp-guards (mostly Catholics) who shamelessly brandished their belt buckles with the inscription Gott Mit Uns. Later on during the “evacuation”/death march in the Gross Rosen KL she was guarded by their brothers- in-Christ fiercely Catholic Croatian ustashas. Ironically and miraculously my godmother was eventually liberated by the “godless” Russian soldiers.
Interestingly all mentioned religious leaders failed to mention a shameful role of Vatican in smuggling the nazi war criminals to South America. I do not expect the current pope to dig in The Vatican archives to investigate this matter.
Well written.
Am amazed that there is so little writtten about the role of catholicism in the Nazi SS and that most recruits to the SS came from Catholic Bavaria.
Religions keep peddeling this myth that Nazism was an athiest ideology???
Robert
this link leads to discussion about a Canadian Minister of State idolising a Croatian Cardinal who assisted the nazi/ustasha regimes. The links and following discussions will provide more material for learning.
Great post, by the way.
Sorry, I have to disagree. Ben Stein said “science leads to killing people”. Andrew Fisher can see that this also applies to atheism and he is right – atheism leads to killing people.
During the term of our own atheist Prime Minister, Bob Hawke, I was innocently stabbed to death no less than six times – in the local supermarket. It was hell. Thank God Jon Howard replaced him and Australia returned to the utopian paradise it was when first settled by Christians where no one does wrong by anyone, ever. It’s so nice to be able to shop knowing I’ll still be alive when I get home.
Of course, for a real laugh check out the religiously charitable sharing and caring going on over at the BBC where Catholics and Anglicans are sharing their views on paedophile priests. Classic stuff.
X wrote: “There is obviously a case to be made for the role of modernism in the rise of early 20th century totalitarian ideologies. There is obviously a case to be made that the works of individual philosophers who happened to be atheists were a part of the bigger mix – Marx more obviously for Sovietism, Nietzsche not so obviously for the totalitarian right.
But these instances of atheism are far from the only conditions the totalitarian ideologies were born from, and as far as I can see there’s little indication that it was the godless aspect of these philosophies that led to disaster. Marx, in commenting that religion was “The Opiate of The Masses”, was alluding to its pervasiveness as something that can’t be wiped out. Contrary to some readings.
People seem to forget that living conditions aren’t what they are today. The start of the 20th century was a period of deep unrest with a lot to contribute in the way of angry, authoritarian motivations.”
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
As a former devoted Stalinist (now an active Anti-Stalinist) I agree with the above.
Ludwik Kowalski
whose new book–”Tyranny to Freedom: Diary of a Former Stalinist” is now available at
www [dot] amazon [dot] com
READER’S REVIEWS ARE ALSO AT THIS WEBSITE.
Comments will be appreciated, either at the above website or in private. Thank you in advance.
kowalskiL@mail.montclair.edu
P.S.
The first chapter is already online at
http://csam.montclair.edu/~kowalski/chapter1.html
“It’s like saying that canned peas pushed Soviet communism” – I like that one a lot. I’ll probably be stealing it.
And the ideas about religious non-profits hurting their own ability to provide services by discriminating against atheists – really well said and original.
Good stuff.
Oh and this post has been Pharyngulated.
How they celebrated Easter down under
Thank you, thank you, thank you! Wonderful words. Thanks Bruce.
It was an odd sensation reading this while I was waiting to see Clash of the Titans at the cinema, which (apparently parodically) was all about humans getting sick of the gods bossing them around and deciding to stand up to them (cf Jensen accusing atheists of attempting to put humans above God). It really was hard not to chuckle while watching.
Glad there are atheists as erudite as you.
On April 5, 2010 (see above) I was promoting my book by offering the first chapter.
The book was not selling very well and I decided to make it available at no cost. The free on-line book was modified significantly in comparison with the printed book. Here is how I am promoting it now:
Dear colleagues,
1) As per our previous correspondence, I want you to know about my new book. Anyone can now read it ONLINE. And it is FREE.
The URL is
http://csam.montclair.edu/~kowalski/life/intro.html
2) Please share this URL with all who might be interested. Thank you in advance.
The title is: “Diary of a Former Communist: Thoughts, Feelings, Reality.”
This 2010 book is my autobiography. It is based on a diary I kept between 1946 and 2004 (in the USSR, Poland, France and the USA).
3) Comments, as always, will be appreciated. I expect my book to be readable by all browsers and under all operating systems. (Please send me a private message immediately if the content is not clearly displayed on your computer screen.)
Ludwik Kowalski
Professor Emeritus
Montclair State University (USA)
kowalskiL@mail.montclair.edu